WHAT THE??? Anime "Destroying" American Society??? IS THIS GUY INSANE???

Gerry

Gareld Mcreadie (FFXIV)
Adventurer
Joined
Apr 12, 2006
Messages
4,593
Age
37
Location
Someone get me out of here!!! /cry
Website
www.myspace.com
Nation Banner
Sandy
Main Job
Paladin-Male
Secondary Job
Warrior-Male
Third Job
Dragoon-Male
Server
Quetzalcoatl
Linkshell
Chibiimers
FFXI
Gerry
FFXIV
Gareld Mcreadie
I came across this on AnimeCentral's site... WHAT THE ****!!!!?!?!?!?!? O_O

Original Report:

By: Elon Glucklich | "Opinion" (Yeah right! >.>) Editor

http://media.www.dailyemerald.com/m....shtml?reffeature=recentlycommentedstoriestab

It wasn't until around the fifth grade that I began to think something was wrong. That year, a strange new cartoon worked its way into the social lexicon of coolness. It was called "Dragon Ball Z" and, for reasons my 10-year-old mind could not articulate, it was making me nervous. Ten years later, I can't help thinking that I could have done something, anything, to stop the tsunami of anime that was to come.

In a society dominated by excess and two-second attention spans, cartoons play a significant role in preparing us for the world. Each can be thought of as a 30-minute babysitter, instilling the kids who watch them with certain values and life lessons. But the landscape has changed.

Before I go any further, I should state the following: No matter who you are - whether you're black, white, Asian, Latino, even Canadian - I don't judge you by the color of your skin. I say this because I direct my comments to the media elites, in Japan and elsewhere, who have taken it upon themselves to flood the airwaves with shows like "Pokemon," "Digimon," and "Yugio" - sorry, "Yu-Gi-Oh!" They all started as card trading games, and should have ended there as well. Instead they've jumped to the mass media, where they're slowly chipping away at our collective moral fiber.

It's not a conspiracy. A conspiracy, by definition, requires that multiple parties are working together to achieve some sort of goal. None of the shows I've seen make nearly enough sense to be working toward anything other than a lackluster battle between Bulbasaur and Charmander and the next commercial break.

Don't believe the threat's real? A report from CNN's Tokyo affiliate in December 1997 documented an incident in which "More than 700 people, mainly school children, were rushed to hospitals Tuesday after suffering convulsions, vomiting, irritated eyes and other symptoms." Was it a gas leak at the local school? No. Were the kids breathing glue out of brown paper bags? No. Were they watching "Pokemon"? You bet your authentic Squirtle trading card they were.

Remember the cartoons you watched as a child, like "Rugrats"? Everyone watched "Rugrats." With his toothless grin and indomitable spirit, Tommy Pickles represented the very best in all of us. He was like a Che Guevara for the MTV generation. Sure, when he and the rest of the Rugrats "grew up" I died a little inside. But still, not a day goes by where I don't take a moment and thank Tommy for the life lessons he taught me. So what is Pokemon teaching the next generation of kids? The virtues of capturing exotic animals and making them fight for your amusement? I already learned that from Michael Vick.

Some of you may be thinking, "That's all well and good, but what about all of the mindless American television?" After all, this country invented mindless television. And networks like VH1 are keeping that proud tradition alive. But the difference here lies in the target audience: Shows like "Flavor of Love" and "Hogan Knows Best" are watched by people who have already been stupid for years, even decades. There's nothing we can do but make them as comfortable as possible.

The next generations of kids aren't even getting a chance. Unless something is done to reverse this trend, we're going to be looking at millions of high school dropouts who don't see the point in going to college unless it teaches them to capture magic crystals. No one wants to see that day. This issue transcends politics, even religion. It's the ethical dilemma of our day and age, one that makes me want to throw my hands in the air, and yell, "Will someone think of the children?"

Response: By Unknown User

http://media.www.dailyemerald.com/m...n/Claims.About.Anime.Ridiculous-3037639.shtml

I could not help but notice that someone at the Daily Emerald actually believes that anime is destroying America's youth. This is a ridiculous claim. If the replacement of American cartoons by Japanese ones destroys American society, then we must assume that cartoons are the largest, most important aspect of American society, which I hope no one is willing to argue. I cannot, however, defend the fact that many of the most popular Japanese cartoon series were based merely on commercially successful trading card games; a phenomenon that does not happen in America. (Transformers was based off of a commercially successful series of action figures, not a trading card game. Keep it straight.)

First, many people claim that Japanese cartoons expose children to poor values, such as trapping exotic animals and forcing them to do battle. Somehow, apparently, this is different from claiming that Harry Potter teaches kids to practice witchcraft. In addition, keep in mind that some of the most iconic American cartoons, such as Bugs Bunny and company, are these days rarely ever aired. If they are, it is only after heavily editing them in order to keep children from being exposed to racism, murder, and deviant sexual activity. If Pokémon is going to teach my daughter to train exotic animals for battle, then Wile E. Coyote is teaching her that if at first you don't succeed, take a smoke break, and then invest in heavy explosives. The worst that will happen is that your skin will turn black, and your hair will poke straight out the back of your head. Second, it needs to be pointed out that Japanese cartoons are not a new phenomenon. They arguably began with Astro Boy in 1963, which is now enjoying a Sunday night time slot on Cartoon Network's Adult Swim. The point is that Japanese cartoons have been a part of Japanese society for at least a generation. Being the case, surely Japanese children have been affected such exposure, yes? Well, there are about 12 times as many murders every year in the U.S. as there are in Japan, about 20 times as much rape, and 80 times as much theft. If these cartoons do indeed instill such horrible values in people, then what are we doing to our children to make them such criminals?

Finally, condemning all Japanese anime because Pokémon is devoid of positive values is horribly unfair. Such a claim ignores the cinematographic masterpieces of Hayao Miyazaki (Spirited Away, Howl's Moving Castle), Satoshi Kon (Paranoia Agent, Paprika), and Hajime Yatate (Cowboy Bebop). If you don't want your kids watching anime, don't let your kids watch it. Just, please don't say anime is destroying our youth. That's just silly.

Obviously the guy who wrote the original repost... is clearly a RETARDED DUMBASS!!!!

Now where is my ACME Brand shotgun?
 
Seriously, this person never saw the old bugs Bunny cartoons and such before they were "toned down" for today's TV standards, they had a dog shoot himself in the head, lay there a for a couple minutes and get back up like nothing happened in one particular cartoon (that scene has been edited to hell last I saw of it). This moron is completely clueless to what kind of stuff we used to put on the air before even cable came out, Popeye and Bluto beating the hell out of each other and busting up everything in the process, racial profiling/slurs in the form of jokes, lots of things that some people would shit themselves over today. We've aired worse is my point, the writer of the first article is a complete dipshit and completely oblivious to the history of cartoons in the US, no research done on the topic, waste of time to write an article on something you know nothing about.
 
Someone obvoisuly doesn't have Boomerang, and obviously hasn't watched cartoons of ages past. All in all, that was a pathetic article that brought nothing to light other than the fact that we're adopting japanese culture more and more everyday, and if this individual really has a problem with acculturation then he should probably kill himself.
 
The man said Rugrats was a good show. He clearly knows nothing.

Also Gerry, you may want to cut back on the sugar.
 
The man said Rugrats was a good show. He clearly knows nothing.

Also Gerry, you may want to cut back on the sugar.

QFT. Even the sugar comment. I guess I can get too hyper now.

Anyways, I stand by my original comment about what that moron wrote.

Rugrats? A Good show? Like Hell! Seriously, if TV shows are teaching kids wrong things, then that means Rugrats might be teaching kids to eat dirt and worms and to be a horrible person to little toddlers. Though that would never happen because since when do kids imitate cartoon shows to a dangerous degree... All I've heard of kids imitating things on TV is WWE stunts and injuring (possibly killing) themselves.

If anything anime is more of a role model than anything in my opinion, like how Naruto aspires to become the best ninja and keep his friends safe, like how Ichigo wants to protect everyone, I can go on for ages, but I don't want to go on and on and on.
 
I'm willing to grant that Dragon Ball Z sucked. Maybe that's their revenge for the "You're a Sap, Mr. Jap" cartoon Rappa posted. Otherwise, the guy's an idiot.
 
Rugrats was an awesome show! I love Tommy and the gang. But the author missed a huge part about Pokemon when he was ranting in it. In every episode, the narrator talked about a life lesson on friendship, trust, never giving up, etc. Every single episode there was a different lesson to learn in life! (Often lessons were repeated.) That angers me so much. He saw the part he wanted to see and wrote about it. Fucking Bias. I hate Bias. Put in all the details before ranting about that.

Dragon Ball Z I liked but then again I was 12. I only ever saw a few episodes about Dragon Ball since it is so behind my time, but Dragon Ball and DBZ were completely different IMO. Dragon Ball was an anime all about adventure. DBZ was about a monster/creature/whatever coming to Earth, threatening to destroy it, somone gets stronger, kills the threat. Rinse and repeat. I still loved it.
 
LOL this society needs to be destroyed as far as I'm concerned... our society is destroying OTHER societies :| cause we're stupid like that.. ah well *shrugs*
 
Yes, because western societies are so awful, we need to all become underaged girl molesting middle-aged men like eastern societies.
 
Dragon Ball Z I liked but then again I was 12. I only ever saw a few episodes about Dragon Ball since it is so behind my time, but Dragon Ball and DBZ were completely different IMO.

I share that opinion. I liked Dragon Ball, but disliked Dragon Ball Z.
 
Man this guy is on my hit list :p seriously tho.... cartoons the main cause of this earths problmes I lawl
 
Putting my two cents in as a parent:
I hate this kind of ignorance. Are we going to become a society that burns books and calls TV the Debil!!! People need to realize that the true problem lies in the parents. My dauhter watches anime with us, reads harry potter, and believes in magic (which in my opinion all children should), she wants to be in a rock band (the next flyleaf is what she said), and loves to blare loud music with me. BUT She is also respectfull, rarely gets into trouble, and is an honor roll student. I think the real issue here is parents not raising their children the way they were raised, i.e. kick the crap out of em for being bad. I used to get spanked, smacked, kicked in the ass, and hell I turned out ok! Im an upstanding citizen, I vote, I work, I take care of my family. Sheesh people get off your high horse and start raising your kids, talk to them, punish them, communicate with them, and most important, love them. This is the trick to raising good kids!!!!!

Damnit .......
*end rant*
 
Putting my two cents in as a parent:
I hate this kind of ignorance. Are we going to become a society that burns books and calls TV the Debil!!! People need to realize that the true problem lies in the parents. My dauhter watches anime with us, reads harry potter, and believes in magic (which in my opinion all children should), she wants to be in a rock band (the next flyleaf is what she said), and loves to blare loud music with me. BUT She is also respectfull, rarely gets into trouble, and is an honor roll student. I think the real issue here is parents not raising their children the way they were raised, i.e. kick the crap out of em for being bad. I used to get spanked, smacked, kicked in the ass, and hell I turned out ok! Im an upstanding citizen, I vote, I work, I take care of my family. Sheesh people get off your high horse and start raising your kids, talk to them, punish them, communicate with them, and most important, love them. This is the trick to raising good kids!!!!!

Damnit .......
*end rant*

QTF....they're your kids, not your friends, act accordingly
 
I absolutely agree. And let me clarify. I did not mean to sound like I am promoting child abuse. There is a line between discipline and abuse and noone should cross it. I just mean to say that parents are too damn relaxed lately. I heard a kid in walmart today demand that her mother buy her this movie. When mom says no, kid procedes to scream and stomp her feet (keep in mind she was like 16). The mother just walks away. Now me, I would have grabbed that kid and said "you better get your shit straight kid cuz if you continue this I will beat you so hard your grandkids will feel it"
 
I absolutely agree. And let me clarify. I did not mean to sound like I am promoting child abuse. There is a line between discipline and abuse and noone should cross it. I just mean to say that parents are too damn relaxed lately. I heard a kid in walmart today demand that her mother buy her this movie. When mom says no, kid procedes to scream and stomp her feet (keep in mind she was like 16). The mother just walks away. Now me, I would have grabbed that kid and said "you better get your shit straight kid cuz if you continue this I will beat you so hard your grandkids will feel it"

QFT.

To This:

I heard a kid in walmart today demand that her mother buy her this movie. When mom says no, kid procedes to scream and stomp her feet (keep in mind she was like 16). The mother just walks away.

The mother was 16 right? Far too young to be a parent.

To This:

Now me, I would have grabbed that kid and said "you better get your shit straight kid cuz if you continue this I will beat you so hard your grandkids will feel it"

Thats definitely some good discipline and parenting skills
 
Now me, I would have grabbed that kid and said "you better get your shit straight kid cuz if you continue this I will beat you so hard your grandkids will feel it"

Gen, you rock :)

I remember once upon a time, this kid had his mother jailed for spanking him in public.

My Mom heard about it, and even though I'd never even entertained the thought of such a thing, or vocalized it, she said to me "if you EVER get the notion to do anything like that, you best hope they keep me in jail'.

My mom is awesome :D
(the above statement was *not* sarcasm)
 
The mother was 16 right? Far too young to be a parent.

Think the kid was the one who was 16.

Also, yeah, the person whining about anime coming to America is just a full-blown idiot. Pokemon doesn't teach family values here, but neither did it in Japan.

I like Rugrats when I was little, yeah. But did it teach me any values? At ALL? Not really. If anything it made me thankful that my parents were a long shot from that horribly irresponsible. I'm sure the person quoted in the OP was also a fan of Doug and his constant psychotic hallucinations and Popeye with his solving problems by hospitalizing people.

That actually sortof isn't the point. Really, none of the above shows were -ever- meant to teach "family values" or have morals, so even using those as a starting comparison is sortof laughable. They were silly cartoons meant as cheap entertaining pass times for kids...

The person who made his huge rant on the topic wasn't even using proper examples - why didn't he mention Arthur, or Babar, or the Busy World of Richard Scarry? Or Franklin, or SESAME STREET? Surely those would all have much better morals than Rugrats or Ren&Stimpy, wouldn't they?

In the end he's just comparing passtime (a) with passtime (b). Pokemon isn't really good for morals, but then it wasn't ever meant to teach morals. Neither was Rugrats as such (well, maybe someone out there learned from the show that haircuts don't hurt, or something) so the argument...just...fails to even begin.

Also, this. Need I say more?
 
Fun Fact: Pope John Paul II actually gave Pokemon his blessing. He said it taught children about friendship, teamwork, and sportsmanship.
 
Back
Top