PS Advent Children + Physics Assignment, lol

Urat

The Chocobo Master
Adventurer
Joined
Feb 8, 2008
Messages
648
Location
Canada
Website
urats-chocobo-blog.blogspot.com
Main Job
Dancer-Male
Secondary Job
Dancer-Male
Third Job
Dancer-Male
Server
Quetzalcoatl
Linkshell
---
For my physics 20 class, we were assigned to find a video, preferably action, that displayed some law breaking or proving physics.

Me being the geek that I am, I chose, Advent Children. Cause that movie totally follows the rules of physics, right?

Turns out it actually does, here's my work I handed in, thought you guys may be interested to find out the characters in AC aren't super human, their planet is just really small:


Physics 20 Video Project
Chosen Movie: Final Fantasy VII: Advent Children
Chosen Scenes:
Scene 1: Chapter 20, Shows two characters jumping from building in chase after an object. After free falling for roughly 38.5 seconds, the character catches the object and lands, (uninjured from the 12 story fall), hops onto his motorbike, and drives away.
This scene has been picked to not prove/disprove any physics, but to actually calculate the acceleration of gravity on this world, since it is painfully obvious that it is most definitely not -9.81. Characters seem to float down through the air with borderline buoyancy.
D= 12 stories x 8 feet = 96 feet = 29.2608 meters
Vi = 0.0 m/s
T = 38.5 s
Acc = ?
Calculations:

D= ViT+1/2AT^2

D= 1/2AT^2
2D = AT^2
(2D)/9T^2)= A
A = 2(29.2609m)/(38.5s^2)

Answer: -0.039 G (Calculated for 2 other scenes and actually added up. So it appears the acceleration of this planet the characters are on is close to the acceleration of the moon)

Scene 2: Chapter 8, Battle Beteen Tifa / Yazoo
Now that we have found the acceleration of gravity, we can explain how halfway through the scene, Tifa (the female character) is launched at a wall, and she is somehow able to “land” on the wall, look up, and then jump back off of it. The total time she is on the wall is .75 seconds, since most of the portion she is portrayed looking up, it is in quarter time. Thus, for every second on screen, it is actually .25 of a second in real time.
Now, we’ll calculate how far she would’ve fallen, Vi starting at 0, and falling for .75 seconds at this slow acceleration due to gravity.
Vi = 0
Acc = -0.039
D= ?

D=Vit+1/2AT^2
D=1/2AT^2
D=1/2(-0.039)(0.75^2)

Answer: 0.01 Meters.
Thus, she only slid down a total of 1 centimeter. If the wall was frictionless. Add in friction, and suddenly it seems very possible to have jumped off the wall in this borderline gravity less world.


Sorry if the work seems funny, it's hard to put in math equations on internets forums.
 
Now solve for F; needed (F=ma) of launching someone in the air, several hundred stories in an =< .03m/s/s environment considering what the escape iV and fV is in the amount of movie T it took.

I don't have time to go through the movie and do it myself, I think this should be interesting to see if that correlates with the rest of the movie lol.

Oh, was FF7AotC CG? If it was, a physics engine could have been used, then I guess the answer would be yes lol.

Good idea for a physics assignment tho ^^.
 
I don't see why someone making a CG movie would go through the process, and money, of either licensing or creating their own physics engines for a bunch of one time shot activities, when simple animation scripts would be a lot easier to make up. It's not like it's a game, where everyone plays differently. It's a movie, where only one possibility happens and thats it.
 
Chances are they used Havok. AC looks a lot like it. Physics engines are used to simulatw thing slike cloth/hair and movements.

Besides it's SE. They already have their own physics engine considering they're a video game company. lol

As for the previous question, we'd need to find clouds mass, or at least earth weight and convert it to mass, to work out newtons then energy. Nothing seems to mention it anywhere... =/
 
Chances are they used Havok. AC looks a lot like it. Physics engines are used to simulatw thing slike cloth/hair and movements.

Besides it's SE. They already have their own physics engine considering they're a video game company. lol

As for the previous question, we'd need to find clouds mass, or at least earth weight and convert it to mass, to work out newtons then energy. Nothing seems to mention it anywhere... =/

If you watch interviews with the creators of AC, they state quite clearly that they wanted to make it CGI so they weren't constricted by physics.
 
If you watch interviews with the creators of AC, they state quite clearly that they wanted to make it CGI so they weren't constricted by physics.

yes, mainyl because it is physicly impossible for any human head to support the amount of hair gel cliud's 'do requires.

But seriously though, it's because it's very hard to make someone jumping 200 feet into the air and slicing up a dragon without cgi.

But just because it's cgi does not mean there is no physic engine, you expect them to manually keyframe each individual frame of hair on clouds head? =/
 
yes, mainyl because it is physicly impossible for any human head to support the amount of hair gel cliud's 'do requires.

But seriously though, it's because it's very hard to make someone jumping 200 feet into the air and slicing up a dragon without cgi.

But just because it's cgi does not mean there is no physic engine, you expect them to manually keyframe each individual frame of hair on clouds head? =/

The point I'm trying to make is that they probably didn't have Newton's laws of physics in mind while they were making it. And its not actually that hard to make someone jump 200 feet in the air and whack a dragon with a sword without making the whole film using CGI. Just throw a green screen behind an actor suspended in a 'falling' motion, stick a fan above or below (depending whether he is falling or rising) and use CGI for the clouds whooshing past, the buildings in the background and a dragon. Its much easier to do it without using CGI for the whole thing; SE chose to use CGI because they wanted an excuse for not abiding by the laws of physics and that it would just be stupid to have a live action Final Fantasy film.

If you're out to point out the technical faults in the Final Fantasy series, you can start by analysing why that in FFXI when you kill a Yagudo you only get 1-2 feathers when it clearly has thousands on its body etc. etc. Or you could just realise its a game/film like everyone else and just enjoy it.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top