Nah I see what you're saying. I know its not common. I have some friends who never fully decided what job they wanted to be and are purely social unassociated players and had never seen Fafnir, Behemoth, Aspid, Simurgh, KA, etc. I'd just bring them for fun to give them the experience. If it becomes a reoccuring presence of the level 54 then I think it'd be more clear that its a bot, but I just didn't like that nothing was mentioned about the name or linkshell of the 54 and immediately being written off as a bot. Most likely because of my own experience of bringing friends along I'm leaning that way.
I do understand theres a pretty good chance it is, I just like giving the benefit of the doubt before stirring stuff up about someone who might be an innocent party. I haven't heard anything other than a level 54 warrior in a different linkshell claimed for them. That to me doesn't instill a guilty verdict instantly. If its been reappearing only during KA with BDS and it logs off right after KA dies, then sure I'll agree with it. But saying only because someone is underleveled and in a different linkshell makes them a bot isn't enough 'proof' provided in my opinion.
The suspicions always there anyway, so its kind of pointless to argue about it I guess.