Cuchulain's Belt vs. Warwolf Belt

[kakashi]

Cuchulain's Belt


[Waist] All Races
DEF:6 HP+15 DEX+6 Attack+10
LV 72 WAR RDM THF PLD DRK BST BRD RNG SAM NIN DRG BLU COR DNC

Warwolf Belt

[Waist] All Races
DEF:6 STR+5 DEX+5 VIT+5 Enmity+3
LV 71 WAR MNK RDM THF PLD DRK BST BRD SAM NIN DRG BLU COR DNC



I wanna replace my warwolf with a cuchulain's is it worth it damage wise?

 

[mdkuser]

warwolf or life belt is the right question.

 

[Bajaratt]

Cuchulain's Belt


[Waist] All Races
DEF:6 HP+15 DEX+6 Attack+10
LV 72 WAR RDM THF PLD DRK BST BRD RNG SAM NIN DRG BLU COR DNC

Warwolf Belt

[Waist] All Races
DEF:6 STR+5 DEX+5 VIT+5 Enmity+3
LV 71 WAR MNK RDM THF PLD DRK BST BRD SAM NIN DRG BLU COR DNC



I wanna replace my warwolf with a cuchulain's is it worth it damage wise?

Warwolf would be probably better for a weapon skill, as well as the enmity for tanking. Cuchulain's belt would only be better for TPing(if you don't need the enmity), but a haste belt would be better than both of them for TPing anyways; so I don't see much use in a Cuchulain's belt at all.

 

[Twinzero]

Cuchulain's belt is for THF only, based on stats. 1 extra dex and 10 extra attack is very nice for SAs, and WSs for THF.

Don't waste your money for NIN

 

[mdkuser]

Cuchulain's belt is for THF only, based on stats. 1 extra dex and 10 extra attack is very nice for SAs, and WSs for THF.

I don't think it's better than warwolf belt really. The only time it would beat it is if your fSTR is caped ( wee wiki if yu dont know about that). Basically, adding str is very usefull untill you reach a certain limit which is determined by your main wpn dmg and the monster's vit vs your str, and once you reach the limit, str just adds attack. So it will be very dependant on what you fight, and the stronger the mob you fight, teh better warwolf belt.

If your accuracy isn't caped on ws, then you should use life belt and this comparison doesn't make sense. If it is caped, then dex doesn't add accuracy, so its just a factor in the secondary modifier of the weapon skills. It's not easy to cap fstr for thf or nin even using hecatomb gears. As long as fstr is not caped, str works like a STR_25% secondary modifier in your WS.

Cuchulain's belt will add 6 dex, dancing edge and evis have 30% modifier so 6 dex or 5 dex doesnt make any difference for dancing edge, it will add 1 base damage to your weapon, that's it, while warwolf will add 2 base dmg: one from str one from dex. ALso the +10 attack is nice, but when you eat meat and have minuet, it loses a lot of values vs other stats. In the end I'm sure warwolf or life belt are better options.