Yeah, Dresdan's post is a little confusing. He's a bit drunk now, you'll have to excuse him. Here's what happened:
I decided to go down to Sea Serpent Grotto to see if the Charybdis window is possibly open, and to maybe solo a few placeholders if I need to.
When I get down to Chary's room, I see members of godblessyou camping and killing placeholders. (Jingod, Jinshorty, Excursion, Blazeoffury, Mecullie, Chaoswrath, and Smg.) Chary pops, and they claim it. I don't think that they can take it with the people they have, so I get some of my ls members to come help me in case GBY wipes.
I watch GBY fight Chary. Things are going bad. They wipe. Chary goes unclaimed and regens back to 100% while they are reraising/raising/waiting on weakened. My ls members are now near SSG, so I decide to go up to the door. I aggro that water elemental near the door to Chary's room casting sneak, because I didn't notice it. So I temp log to get rid of it instead of fighting it. When I come back, everything is fine. GBY is still resting up, the water elemental isn't even near them, so I know they didn't aggro it raising. (This is an important point later in the story.)
ESP members arrive, we claim Chary. GBY members are still not ready to fight him again. We claim Chary and fight him down to 1% health, and things go wrong. Our people start dying. Then the only people left alive are me and a whm (Zaevier), but we only need a couple hits or one good whm Holy or Banish 3 to finish Chary off. Chary goes for Zaevier, and then goes yellow. Mecullie STEALS CHARY, and GBY finishes it off.
At this point, GBY starts calling US thieves. They also say that I tried to MPK them with a water elemental they didn't even aggro. They say we couldn't have finished if off, but it was at 1%, and even with just a brd and a whm, we could have killed it with one attack.
I'd like to say that some of the GBY members are not complete assholes, but
Jingod
Jinshorty
Excursion
Mecullie
. . . Go fuck yourself, you third-rate hacks. You wiped to Chary when he had 60% life left. Your nin couldn't handle Chary, and even when you tried to kite Chary, you still wiped. You needed us to get it down to 1% so you could steal the kill. You call us thieves for taking it after you wiped and were weakened? Fuck you.