NIN tanking in K Osode

If a 2nd BRD is going to hinder the party why get a BRD period? Just getting a 5th DD would be better then right?

Also a 2nd BRD means a backup healer and the puller just has to sing 2 songs and thats it. He doesn't have to sleep anything or Finale the mob. The 2nd BRD can do all that easily making things much easier on everyone. Plus the 3 DDs will be putting up huge numbers and what DD doesn't like that.
 
Last edited:
If a 2nd BRD is going to hinder the party why get a BRD period? Just getting a 5th DD would be better then right?

lol wth are you talking about? thats almost like saying if 2 "insert job here" are going to gimp a party why have a "insert job here" at all. i think you were the one that ranted and raved about 2 brds and got all your info from 'eyeballing' the numbers on the screen.
 
as far as max exp per hour goes i thought it was determined that swapping out another DD for a brd/cor was useless

I was being sarcastic with my comment and it was directed at this. You said swapping out a DD with a 2nd BRD/COR would be useless. So why have a BRD/COR in there period when a DD would be better. Just have 5 DDs and a RDM then. Does that make sense?
 
A SECOND Bard is useless IF they don't increase the exp/hour, THEN you're better off with a fourth DD. You'd still need the first bard.
 
i think you were the one that ranted and raved about 2 brds and got all your info from 'eyeballing' the numbers on the screen.
I argued that Dual wielders could eat attack food on Mamools in certain situations and no one would believe me but it has been proven here again that they can eat attack food when geared properly with the right support.
 
Whms don't attack in merit parties, so why have them at all! They aren't doing their share of the DoT to the mob so they are completely useless.
 
I argued that Dual wielders could eat attack food on Mamools in certain situations and no one would believe me but it has been proven here again that they can eat attack food when geared properly with the right support.

you can eat apple pies on mamools with the right support. In a perfect world I can outdamage you naked as a level 1 whm vs your 75 nin with the right support.

I was being sarcastic with my comment and it was directed at this. You said swapping out a DD with a 2nd BRD/COR would be useless. So why have a BRD/COR in there period when a DD would be better. Just have 5 DDs and a RDM then. Does that make sense?

i never said to take out the first bard. brd/cor = brd OR cor
 
you can eat apple pies on mamools with the right support. In a perfect world I can outdamage you naked as a level 1 whm vs your 75 nin with the right support.

What are you trying to say? Can you not be an efficeint DD eatting attack food on Mamool with the right support?
 
What are you trying to say? Can you not be an efficeint DD eatting attack food on Mamool with the right support?

im saying with the right support you can do anything.

BOF parsed ~72-75% acc with meat on mamools/puks, do u think that will beat out a nin eating sushi with close to ~85-90% acc on mamools/puks?
 
Last edited:
im saying with the right support you can do anything.

BOF parsed ~72-75% acc with meat on mamools/puks, do u think that will beat out a nin eating sushi with close to ~85-90% acc on mamools/puks?

He beat a WAR/NIN who parsed 92% accuracy by 11% total damage.
 
im saying with the right support you can do anything.

BOF parsed ~72-75% acc with meat on mamools/puks, do u think that will beat out a nin eating sushi with close to ~85-90% acc on mamools/puks?

If I was on mamool/puks camp my accuracy would be a whole lot higher, I was at Nyzul mamools where there are lurkers and infilitrators to incredibly hinder my accuracy.
 
He beat a WAR/NIN who parsed 92% accuracy by 11% total damage.
He's also geared better than the WAR is; of course he'd parse higher.
 
Here's my parser results from today, had a better party, it was located at Mamool Ja Staging point, camped on the hill where we could pull from southern and northern giving us Skoffins, Lurkers, and Infilitrators.

Necroprettyparse.jpg


Blazeoffury - 75nin/war (33.69%)
Siresativa - 75thf/nin (33.16%)
Anderoc - 75war/nin (33.08%)
Necrosis - 75brd/nin (0.00%)
Raye - 75brd/whm (0.00%)
Kuroe - 75rdm/whm JP (Also would not reccommend partying with him/her, they don't haste or dia regularly.) (0.07%)

My equip and food stays the same in this party as it did the last party. The only difference was Necrosis was singing min/mad. I parsed at 83.43% acc using meat, while the other meat user (Siresativa) parsed at 83.51%. Both of us parsed over the war (Anderoc).

Necroparsenumbers.jpg


Again posting the original Parser data to show you where my numbers are coming from.

As of current, I will stick with my hypothesis from yesterday that a ninja geared as mine can feasibly use meat in the southern Mamool Ja Staging point camps. The only problems to occur would be from skoffins using wind wall.

New Hypothesis: Using a bard that will do Madx2 will make Northern Mamool Ja Staging point camp a feasible meat using camp for those who like 90-94% acc, but a second bard who uses Mad/Min is still a feasible meat camp if you don't mind parsing a little bit lower at around 84% acc, but still putting out enough damage to make up for the lack of accuracy.

Sometime this weekend I plan to try the "perfect" setup for meat, Brd, Brd, Cor, Rdm, War, Me. Mar/Mar/Min/Mad/Huntroll/DAroll.

Disclaimer: My study sample is still small, so do not hold my experiment to be the exact truth as it is yet to be studied to a full extent.
 
Blaze I'd love to come on my War/sam to outparse you. lemme know when you wanna do it.
 
Blaze I'd love to come on my War/sam to outparse you. lemme know when you wanna do it.

Olrox, these parses aren't about who's doing the most damage, we're focusing on accuracy here, I just happened to come out on top both times.
 
Just curious who was first voke in the 2nd parse and what the other DDs gear setup and merits looked like. I'm guessing also since the RDM was not up to par he did not gravity the appropriate mobs either which would of boosted everyones accuracy just a little bit more.
 
Last edited:
good stuff bof, glad u got some numbers unlike some guestimations we had before =P. be nice to see another nin similarly geared eating sushi with you.
 
Just curious who was first voke in the 2nd parse and what the other DDs gear setup and merits looked like. I'm guessing also since the RDM was not up to par he did not gravity the appropriate mobs either which would of boosted everyones accuracy just a little bit more.

Let me talk to them today and find out everything, I don't want to post false information.
 
Back
Top