The concept certainly is an interesting one and like many new ideas, it has it's potential and some flaws. I'm not gonna repeat what everyone said but here are a few observations I made reading the posts.
1) What about the members CK have now? Maybe I am reading this wrong but from what I understand, CK will "train" and teach those that will apply to this program. That means not only teaching them basic end-game or HNMs tactics but also helping with quests, missions, ZM, etc. Now say you have 15 people applying, you need 8 people in the "major leage" CK and only 2 make the cut, that means you helped 13 people and spent a lot of time for nothing (with regards to your own personal goals). Now you gotta start over and probably over and over until you get the people you want. I don't know anyone in CK but are they prepared to redo the same thing all over again multiple time?
If however CK's LS is not to help with such things, so the recruit canlearn on their own, then how is this different from any other social LS? Yes it's a way for you to see who has skills and can get out of a jam, but why would people join this new LS rather then another social in the first place?
2) IF CK's members are'nt helping with ZM, others will. Meaning these potential recruit will befriend members of other shells. When the time come to go waste 12 hours of your day at Ullik, they might decide to join those friends that did help them get there inthe first place.
(AGAIN, this is just an observation, I am not saying CK will not help, I don't know that, I'm just following point 1 and thinking out loud.)
3) If you can observe them, they can observe you. I mean they will also get a chance to judge CK's rules, members and policies. Now I've never heard anything wrong about CK, that's not the point. I'm sure you are very confident in your LS. But a potential good recruit might witness unwanted drama or misinterprete a lot/gear handling situation and decide to walk out. Agreed, this is a good thing for both sides, but all I'm saying is your LS will be walking on thinner ice then others. Every LS has drama, that drama might scare away potential recruit before they even get a chance to build loyalty towards CK.
Damn it I had something else but lost it, phone just rang... Anyway one thing I want to add is I don't see why it's necessary to train someone for 2 months before they are ready to do end-game stuff. If you don't learn to not stay behind a Wyrm after one fight or how not to get aggroed by Faust after it destroyed you once, you won't learn after 2 months either. Plus 2 months of reading "Faust is out, careful." will still get you kill the first time you go there all "All right I'm finally in Sky... where's everyone... what? BAM! Oh, so that's Faust".
Finally, again, I don't know anyone in CK personally and I have no problem with the LS but what bugs me is this:
Anaeran said:
I just think if we take a little time to share some knowledge, without handing everything to them on a silver platter (obviously nothing learns you a dragon fight like fighting the dragon firsthand), it will greatly increase the quality of our server as a whole if nothing else. Yes CK is looking for talent, there are some selfish motives behind this. But even if we don't catch us any fine recruits, we'll at least make this server a better environment to play in. Its pretty cool to be able to have that impact in itself if we succeed.
Altho your intentions are noble, you are'nt carrying the weight of Quetzy on your shoulders. I'm sure there is a lot of good players out there that have learned without CK's help.
So en resume, I hope your current members are prepared to spend a lot of time helping new 60-70 players that will apply. If not this is just another Social LS with a promise of one day joining a Sky LS if you pass the test or make the cut.
Like I said in the beginning, it's a good idea, but it has some flaws. One of them being human nature and looking out for oneself first and foremost.