Gonna address some of your posts Shaggy
About Bazaars, I mean yeah you can do it but the game's community isn't where it used to be. Think about it this way. This site was peaking in 2004 and 2005. Think of how the internet community operated as a whole back then. It was a lot more tight knit and the average computer skills of each individual was higher than it is now. Now it's the Facebook era. People aren't going to jump at a site like they used to. Also, this leads into my next answer.
Other sites. Even back when we were in our prime we were the only server on FFXI that had a dedicated and popular forum for its players. There's some other sites:
BG -
http://bluegartr.com - general purpose
Allakhazam -
http://ffxi.zam.com
KI -
http://killingifrit.com
FFXIAH -
http://ffxiah.com
All of these sites were at one point in time or are now the most popular destination for FFXI players that want to post on a forum. Right now, FFXIAH and BG are the two kings. That likely won't change, as this game is not growing further from where it currently stands. We can not and really never have been able to compete with those sites. FFXIAH completely controls the crafting and event scheduling department of things, which is why I was in favor of removing the forums here. We can't really take that back. Our user base due to the Midgardsormr merge is going to be fractured to the point where it won't really work out. Not enough of us on here, even now, play anymore either.
There's no need for a new direction in the site, we just need to compress it, bring it back to a FFXI perspective, preferably under the QCDN name instead of "Eorzea Sun" (FFXIV term) and enjoy the time we have.
Truncated, the board died because some people wanted to try to compete with BG for FFXIV and got badly beaten down. That and FFXIV was terrible. A lot of both.
Back in 2005 and 2006, most of the members here posted on BG for more advanced mechanical discussion of the game and came here for shooting the breeze, talking about server stuff, organizing stuff with friends, etc. That's what this board needs to be about now, and it can EASILY be recaptured.
edit 1: We can't branch out to other servers. They never knew about the site and asking new players to register here will be extremely difficult to do even on Quetz, much less other servers entirely.
Our user base is really large on here, believe it or not. More people logged in a few days ago than I've seen in years. We can do just fine getting the core back. If we do that, people will gravitate naturally to the site. But it's near impossible to pull players from other servers that never knew of this site when it was truly great to come here on a whim when there are existing, larger options available like BG and FFXIAH