I don't think you are wrong in taking in the kitty.
My girlfriend had a similar thing happen to her cat. A neighbour a couple houses down did try to steal her cat. The difference being they took her cats collar off and would keep him in their house for days feeding him etc. She wasn't sure what to do about it. Though she didn't have proof they took his collar off, it wasn't something the cat himself use to pick at. Not to mention they knew Chino belonged to her and still fed him and would keep him in.
I told her to pay them a visit and in not such kind words tell them to back off and visit the pound or humane society if they wanted a cat. A lot of people shouldn't own animals. I detest 'young' adults or college aged kids that will take in/buy a cat and not bother getting it fixed and getting it's shots etc.
Neither one of my cats have collars, but neither one of them are outdoor cats.
My girlfriend had a similar thing happen to her cat. A neighbour a couple houses down did try to steal her cat. The difference being they took her cats collar off and would keep him in their house for days feeding him etc. She wasn't sure what to do about it. Though she didn't have proof they took his collar off, it wasn't something the cat himself use to pick at. Not to mention they knew Chino belonged to her and still fed him and would keep him in.
I told her to pay them a visit and in not such kind words tell them to back off and visit the pound or humane society if they wanted a cat. A lot of people shouldn't own animals. I detest 'young' adults or college aged kids that will take in/buy a cat and not bother getting it fixed and getting it's shots etc.
Neither one of my cats have collars, but neither one of them are outdoor cats.