Ranpha said:
2. All player vs. Monster. PvP would be laughable in this game.
The other versions of the game had Challenge Mode. So PvP wouldn't be laughable, it's just not implemented at this time and no news of it ever being placed into the game can be found.
As per itemization from the guy with the questions: Rare items are mostly crafted. You gather special materials from rare boss spawns, within your instance, or just from being totally lucky and them dropping. There are also some items of rare state that are dropped in their usable state.
This game is all about getting items and craft materials. Thought the story is good, if you do not like treasure hunting your enjoyment will be short spanned. Personally, I love the game but that has a lot to do with me loving the story.
The controller part... This game is a console port. Every PSO game has been a console game until lately and therfore they are built for consoles. So the game is meant to be played with a controller and it shows, believe you, me.
Aside from all of that I think everyone else pretty much answered all your questions. I will tell you this before you go off canceling other subscriptions. This game doesn't work like FFXI or WoW and thus the addiction factor probably will not present itself. You'll probably end up playing this game like a console game, a lot at first and then in pick-up, put-down relaxation.
Also, stay away from the official and PSOWorld forums. They suck, realllllllly bad unless you like to whine or can't RTFM. PSOWorld has a nifty items database though.
Enjoy
**Edit** To Skaw: Your grade from joining a party in progress doesn't start as C. It depends on what block the party is in and how much you contribute from that point on. I've gotten an A once. Usually I get a B because I do not join parties over 5-6 min long. If you're doing De Ragan, 5-6 min will get you a C because it's so short.