Just double checking (I think I know the answer), but HQ staffs would be more beneficial than Kirin's Pole for Helix spells, correct?
Yes thats correct.
Copy and pasted from somewhere i forgot >
We will assume the helix formula is correct even though it isn't exact. Using the FFXI Magic DMG Calculator...
Cryohelix
With Alkalurops against a pudding(89INT) with Hailstorm/Eb:
75+83 = 192/tick
With HQ staff against a pudding(89INT) with Hailstorm/Eb:
75+78 = 209/tick
With NQ staff against a pudding(89INT) with Hailstorm/Eb:
75+77 = 198/tick
On a monster that takes less magic damage(I couldnt think of a specific INT value of any certain mobs, so I assumed 104INT):
With Alkalurops against a mob with 104INT with Hailstorm/Eb:
75+83 = 128/tick
With HQ staff against a mob with 104INT with Hailstorm/Eb:
75+78 = 138/tick
With NQ staff against a mob with 104INT with Hailstorm/Eb:
75+77 = 130/tick
Ionohelix
With Alkalurops against a pudding(89INT) with Thunderstorm/Eb:
75+77 = 179/tick
With HQ staff against a pudding(89INT) with Thunderstorm/Eb:
75+67 = 183/tick
With NQ staff against a pudding(89INT) with Thunderstorm/Eb:
75+67 = 174/tick
On a monster that takes less magic damage(I couldnt think of a specific INT value of any certain mobs, so I assumed 104INT):
With Alky against a mob with 104INT with Thunderstorm/Eb:
75+77 = 118/tick
With HQ staff against a mob with 104INT with Thunderstorm/Eb:
75+67 = 117/tick
With NQ staff against a mob with 104INT with Thunderstorm/Eb:
75+67 = 113/tick
<
As kirins has equal int to alk maths is same.
But with kirins your gonna lose a huge magic accuracy boost too.