Putting this here, cleaned up a bit. I will update this as I progress through Vanguard: Saga of Heroes.
Pros:
- Challenging content for various situations (solo, group, raid etc)
- Adventuring (basic exping/content), Diplomacy and Crafting: all 3 of the major spheres of the game are both entertaining and addicting as you can improve your character in a number of ways.
- Well paced character progression: you don't become level 50 over night
- Amazing graphics/world flow that makes simply roaming the world an incredible gaming experience
- Hardcore Bannings of RMT. If you report someone selling gold the GMs in this game will ban them on the spot. There is no "we're looking into it..." bullshit, you get results here. Also, the GMs don't all have sticks up their asses. Joke around with them as they help you with your issues, they seem to enjoy their jobs here.
-Fun, strategic combat system that promotes smart gameplay over mindless button smashing. If you suck, you don't progress.
- You can't delevel, but rather you accumulate "exp debt" which requires you to earn back that lost exp before you're able to progress to the next level. Kind of a nifty new take on it imo, since you can easily dig yourself a pretty big hole if you're not careful.
- The line between strong players and weak players is once again well defined in an MMO. Weak players won't reach the hardest areas in this game, as they've been able to in both FF and WoW.
The EQ dev team once again is not shy about holding the "casual" player back behind their more dedicated gamers when it comes to content progression. While some may argue this isn't fair to the casual gamers, think about end game in both FFXI and WoW and I'm sure it isn't hard to see why this is listed as a PRO rather than a CON in online gaming.
- Planning ahead: The Devs (2 guys from EQ1 and 2 teams) have recognized the importance of looking to the future when designing MMO content and thus have already planned out their next 7 expansions. This ensures no gigantic content mishaps (from what I hear, WoW expansions have been notorious for this) that negate all your previous efforts. It will also ensure the game is running for many, many years to come.
Cons:
- Launch bugs (expected with the launch of any brand new MMO). Good news is the devs of this game are extremely vigilant in making the game absolutely flawless and are quickly working to counter these minor issues.
- If you don't have a quality machine to run it on you won't be able to fully appreciate the splendor of the world environments. I bought a new computer simply to play this game on its highest quality settings and I have to admit, there's nothing out there that compares. I was blown away when I finally cranked it up to HQ graphics.
- Some features, such as the /raid command, aren't in the game yet (though will be relatively soon). This makes big guild events kind of tough to manage at this stage, however, early on most guilds won't be needing the raid function anyways, so its not really a big deal.
- You will be hooked. This game is phenominal and as such will likely suck you in before you even realize it. Don't let work, family and friends suffer as a result of....yeah you know how it goes
Other than that, I'd easily say this game will replace WoW as top dog in MMO gaming. It would be cool to see some of the more serious gamers here pick this up and try it out.