Your military is extremely impressive but you elect morons to control it, and you give them full unconditional control as of late. This "umbrella" you speak of casts too dark a shadow at times and I fear the day a real adversary knocks at your door. A country with a larger military power than pipe bombs and human shields.
A good example of a stupid person with his head up his ass. Obviously no country matters compared to the might of the American empire. I cannot wait until the day you beg us for our fresh water resources... but I guess you will just invade if you don't get your way.
Imo, America would be a much more impressive and healthy nation if even just a third of the accounted for military spending went to homeland structures rather than blowing up the earth.
I'd like to reiterate Nyett, I do not support realist power projection and military spending that is as far as I remember 5 times that of countries that conservatives in the Pentagon see as a threat - China (for the record I don't see China as a threat). 5 times as much and working from a foundation that is way ahead of the game.
My point is simply US military spending and the US military umbrella is nice for countries under it in the case they don't have to spend money on the military. Canada's geostrategic position and relations with the US put it in the position that it probably wouldn't require a large standing army in the first place because lets face it we aren't fighting each other along with Iroquois' and the Huron Confederacy. For nations like Japan the story is much different because of a different strategic position they face, they would most likely have to spend a great deal more on a defense budget.
Quite frankly the biggest adversary America has concerning itself and issues of defense spending and the military industrial complex is itself, threat projection and conservative policy feeds the further entrenchment of these groups into places of privilege and that is the biggest hurdle America has in the realm of defense and military.
That old guy with his head up his ass is actually Irish first off, second off it was an off-hand comment. Third, tell me why Canada is of great geopolitical relevance. Four, tell me why you would even want Canada to be geopolitically relevant. Five, this professor whom even I am sure I would have disagreements with on somethings has been publishing and teaching for at least 30 years so I would tend to give credence to things he said. Six, did I mention it was a joke.
If I were to say "Canada doesn't matter" if I was serious of course I would phrase it in a more palatable rhetoric, but it would be the same as when I was in Japan and Japanese were afraid of a democrat being elected in the US because of the democrats greater tendency to engage China which conservative politicians saw as a zero-sum game for support and favor. Often I would respond simply, considering China's importance in Asia and long-standing engagement with Japan, why shouldn't the US focus more on China in their relations? The same applies with Canada in a sense, Canada is important in certain aspects of our economy such as energy resources, but in other areas Canada is a non-issue and when it comes to the military Canada is not of great concern to the United States and why would either of us want that to be otherwise.
Imo, America is arrogant in a lot of respects and this arrogance is fed by ignorance and blithe generalizations also imo a lot of anti-American sentiment exists and is often fed by ignorance and blithe generalization. I will be the first to admit maybe what I said came off as somewhat arrogant and derisive, though it wasn't meant to be, but responding in a manner that only mirrors what you perceive me doing buys right back into silly power positioning.