Yet Vick can't take his team all the way. Yes I know The Saints were in the NFC South along with the Falcons, but years prior why can't he get the job done if he's so amazing? As far as Vick's charges they're far more serious than Johnson's charges because Vick is getting federal indictments where as Tank was only held in prison at Cook County.
Vick is risking federal prison. I can't remember, but isn't there still controversy over Vick's water bottle hidden compartment? Micheal Vick has a trail as much does Tank, Pacman, and 9 of the Begal players.
As far as Grossman versus Vick I would still rather have Grossman who had freak injuries as a quarter back over Vick who simply can't get the job done. Yes you will bring up the point that Grossman didn't get the job done when he was on the field in the Super Bowl. What you wont mention though is how the Bears defense wasn't doing a damn thing to stop the short passes. That is a big flaw with cover 2 is either the defense gets beat on short passes trying to protect the long bomb, or the defense gets beat at the safety zones by a deep post route going towards the middle of the field.
Now lets bring up Vick's short game as that is all he has. He ran for 1,000 yards as a QB now isn't that the job of a RB? Ya Vick can throw some what, but he barely breaks a 52% on his completion rating (Grossman 54%). Then Rex also threw for over 3,000 yards lets not forget his 45 sacks versus Grossman's 21. Yes go ahead bring up the Bears Offensive line. Vick lost about 7 so did Rex (both coming out to be 6.7 yards if you want to be exact). You want to glorify Vicks running why did he only have 2 touch downs running?
Now we have to bring in the running game as that is what Da Bears focus on offense wise. Thomas Jones out ran Warrick Dunn had more TDs. Cedric Benson 6 TD 647 yards only playing the last few weeks with some red zone touches.
The Bears put forth more of a team effort for winning rather than focusing on one aspect. As Tim said Alge Crumpler was Vick's favorite target. Face it Ashley Lelie isn't a #1 WR. Where as Grossman has Mushin Muhammed, Bernard Berrian (shouldn't be a #2), Mark Bradley, Desmond Clark (even though I don't like him), and Rashied Davis. Now I highly doubt these receivers would be getting many TD, and Desmond Clark who isn't a great catch and run TE nor does he have the hands of the new generation TE of Shockey, Gates, Heap, and Crumpler. Yes yes I know Clark had 6 TDs, but it's taken him too damn long to develop.
Football is a team sport not just a one man show which Vick pretty much is. Although it is Sports Center and they only show clips of people's favorite players. Vick is a one note kind of player that is a scrambling QB until he was put into a west coast offense where short plays dominate and we all know Vick doesn't have the cannon that Grossman does.
Vick
Grossman
Grossman has nothing but leg problems. Vick has problems from scrambling, being tackled more than a QB should, and sacked. Vick will continue to have these problems as long as he's a rushing QB because he's going to get hit a lot. Which will present a problem for a lot of people that would be interested in Vick when he becomes a free agent. They will look at his injuries the amount of times he's been hit with in the seasons. He will be signed by someone if he's not thrown into prison, but the chance of him retiring due to multiple injuries is great as it is with pretty much any scrambler.
You can bring up games he missed, but look at the injuries as to why he missed them.