hellstorm, again:
I actually said the Errant Houppelande is one of the pieces that can be replaced by Crimson Scale Mail seeing as Yigit has been introduced, albeit after I quit. It is certainly a good piece to use when nuking due to the INT bonus, though for low resist mobs it is likely the extra stats it provides will make only a slight difference (if any) to enfeebling spells; in which case Dalmatica is more suitable. Errant or Mahatma can’t be completely ruled out though, as it still has –Enmity. I’m generalizing with a lot of this and different situations may require different setups, though if you really needed the stats you could simply swap out other slots. Oh, and there are still better pieces for solo than W.body.
That said, Crimson to RDM is not as Osode is to BRD. I don’t pretend to know a lot about BRD, but the –Enmity on Errant and the exact same stats (even more on Mahatma!) would seem to make it more useful for end-game encounters. And no, meriting is not end-game.
More on Dalmatica; even if Refresh and Haste don’t take up much MP, if you’re casting on quite a few players it may take up more than you’re getting back through Refresh/Ballad/whatever; Dalmatica helps to lighten this. You’re not necessarily ‘wasting’ MP by not using Convert every 10 minutes, in fact I find the opposite is true and players prefer to prolong each convert as much as possible so it can be used when actually needed; it’s not as if you’re going to dump your MP every 10 mins to do this. This practice is different while meriting of course, but again … not end-game!
With regards to MDB: I have not mentioned Magic Defense Bonus in any of my posts, and personally I don’t consider it to be a big factor in using the item; I would use Dalmatica for the Refresh alone. Despite this, it still has some use on certain attacks, whereas –Breath damage % has almost none. –3 Enmity too, is actually useful, whereas -10% to breath damage is not a plus in any way; unless you suffer from enormous amounts of L2P and are constantly standing in breath zone.
I’m sure some of this has been repeated now… try actually reading the post, you might take in more than a few words.
Edit: imisible isn't even a fucking word. l2stopmakingshitup?